Hi Stew, as you can probably guess, I've spent some significant time on this issue before getting started on my radial engine project, and what I came up with is that for practical purposes in a scale engine, the offset of actual angular timing is insignificant, completely, and the easiest method is master rod, slave rod as most aircraft engines. As an aside, most all are odd numbered to avoid harmonic vibrations which are multitudinous in a radial engine, and an even number multiplies them by at least twice. One thing I've seen and looked at, is a set up pretty much as your first model shown, the one which appears to have a ring with all the cylinders free. I have seen this, but was not aware one rod was attached, and thus it acts like a master rod set up. I have also seen the same setup however the "ring" was substantial, with a full bushing in it, all the rods were free, and the ring was connected to the inside of the crank case with two or three straps, so it articulates with the crank while never changing its angular relationship with any of the rods. It was among the earliest full size aircraft engines, and did fly, so it is a working design. I think Pratt and Whitney worked out a maximum of about six degrees of difference between the two cylinders furthest apart in ignition timing, using the master rod set up, and compensated for it in both electrical ignitions and in magnetos by slight changes in the ignition cams and their angles. Again, something that scaled down, is too small to be an impact on design. I'd like to pursue the "sleeve on the crank with nine slave rod" idea when I get my current radial engine done, just because I haven't seen it duplicated anywhere and have only read about it. I have seen working hydrostatic drive units that use the same concept as they need dead even power in all cylinders when working with the high pressure of serious hydraulics, and the "leashed collar" system equalizes all the angular movements for all the rods and cylinders exactly. I just thought I'd toss that into the mix, since it is Stew, and I am building a radial, so I can get away with such a comment. Mad Jack
